OpenClaw 替代方案：更安全、更簡單，以及代管的選擇

替代方案

1. 

   Rakazo

   Rakazo

   US$10/月

   Open-source, self-hostable platform for persistent AI bots that each get a job, a computer, memory and routines, using the model you choose.

   優點

   • Open source (Apache-2.0) and fully self-hostable, including with local models
   • Choice of model per bot, including existing Claude or ChatGPT subscriptions
   • Bots keep working on schedules and triggers with their own cloud computer
   • Approval controls over which actions a bot may take on its own

   缺點

   • Still in beta, with frequent releases
   • You supply and pay for the model on the hosted plans, unless you buy Rakazo credits
   • Telegram, WhatsApp and iMessage/SMS are only available when self-hosted
   • More setup than a single chat app
   前往 Rakazo
2. 

   Hermes Agent

   Nous Research

   US$20/月

   Free, MIT-licensed AI agent from Nous Research that runs on your own machine or server, learns reusable skills, and chats with you on Telegram, Slack and more.

   優點

   • Free and MIT licensed, and runs on hardware you control
   • Writes and refines its own skills from experience, on top of persistent memory and cross-session search
   • One gateway for 20+ chat platforms, including Telegram, Discord, Slack, WhatsApp, Signal and email
   • Run several separate agents as profiles, each with its own model, memory and skills, and let them talk in group chats
   • Model-agnostic, with a one-command import from OpenClaw

   缺點

   • Setup expects comfort with the command line and with running your own server
   • Model costs are on you unless you use free models, and hosted web search, images and speech need a paid Nous Portal plan or your own keys
   • iMessage needs a separate BlueBubbles server on a Mac
   • No native mobile app; Android support is a command-line install through Termux
   前往 Hermes Agent
3. 

   Grok Bot

   SpaceXSI (formerly xAI)

   US$30/月

   Always-on AI agents from SpaceXSI that run on a shared cloud computer, sign in to your apps and finish multi-step work while you're away.

   優點

   • Bots work on their own cloud computer, so tasks keep running when your laptop or phone is closed
   • Can operate websites and apps that have no API, using saved logins it never sees in plain text
   • Several Bots can run in parallel, message each other and share one workspace
   • Routines can run on a schedule or after an event, and a Bot can learn a task from a recorded demonstration of up to 10 minutes
   • Can place phone calls to US businesses for you and send a summary afterwards
   • Native apps for macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS and Android, plus Slack

   缺點

   • No free plan and no standalone price: the cheapest way in is the $30/month Premium plan
   • Usage comes from a weekly pool shared with Grok and Cursor, and SpaceXSI does not publish how much work that pool covers
   • No model picker: Grok Bot chooses the model for each task and does not show which one it used
   • All Bots on an account share one computer, files and logins; the docs say not to use separate Bots as a security boundary
   • Users report Amazon blocks it from shopping as an unauthorized AI agent; Amazon hasn't commented
   • Still labelled beta, with no browser version
   前往 Grok Bot
4. 

   Poke

   The Interaction Company of California (Cognition)

   US$19/月

   A personal AI assistant you text in iMessage or Telegram that connects to your email, calendar and apps and messages you first when something needs attention.

   優點

   • Nothing to install: you sign up with a phone number and text it like a contact
   • Messages you first, using your connected services and memory
   • Free plan with no credit card, and email and calendar included
   • Connects to Gmail, Outlook, Google Calendar, Notion, GitHub, Linear and many more apps, plus custom integrations through MCP
   • Shareable automation recipes, and developers can build their own

   缺點

   • Uses your data to train its AI models unless you choose Maximum Privacy
   • WhatsApp support is limited to some markets
   • Only one phone number per account
   • Does not say which AI models it uses, and does not publish how many credits each plan includes
   • Now owned by Cognition, so the product's direction may change
   前往 Poke
5. 

   Manus

   Manus

   US$20/月

   General-purpose AI agent that researches, builds websites, slides, videos and games, and runs automations on its own cloud computer.

   優點

   • Turns one prompt into finished output: research reports, websites, slides, videos and playable games
   • Automations can start from a schedule or an event in a connected service such as Gmail, Slack or Notion
   • Video Editor and Game Dev let you edit what the agent made instead of regenerating it
   • Free plan to try it, with apps for web, iOS, Android, macOS and Windows

   缺點

   • Credit-based pricing makes costs hard to predict, and long or failed runs can use up credits
   • Free daily credits are capped at 1,500 a month and only work in the Lite mode
   • A built-in training opt-out is listed only for Team plans
   • Several plans share the Pro name and differ only by credit amount
   前往 Manus
6. 

   Perplexity Teammates

   Perplexity

   US$200/月

   Persistent Perplexity agents, each with its own computer, browser and memory, that own ongoing work and watch Slack, GitHub and Linear. Max-only web preview.

   優點

   • Run several teammates, each on its own isolated computer and browser with separate sessions
   • Watches Slack, GitHub, Linear and other connected tools, acts on changes and reaches out when it needs you
   • Pick the model per teammate or task, with Claude Opus 5.5 as the default
   • Splits a goal into parallel agent tasks, and teammates in a Project share context and hand work to each other
   • You can take over a teammate's desktop and steer it, and it can't view your saved credentials

   缺點

   • Only on Perplexity Max at $200 a month; Pro and Enterprise plans are excluded by default
   • Research preview whose behavior may change
   • Web only for now; the iOS app is only promised soon
   • Usage draws on credits, and parallel agents, large files and frequent automations use more
   • No published cap on teammates and no published credit cost per task
   前往 Perplexity Teammates

功能

功能

	OpenClaw	Rakazo	Hermes Agent	Grok Bot	Poke	Manus	Perplexity Teammates
網路搜尋	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是
圖像生成	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	?未知	✓是	✓是
語音模式	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	?未知
檔案上傳	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是
記憶	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是
代你執行操作	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是
應用程式整合	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是
自主運作	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是
主動傳訊息給你	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是
可執行多個機器人	✓是	✓是	✓是	✓是	?未知	?未知	✓是